For SEIS the period runs for three years from the share issue, with some investor tests starting at incorporation. For EIS it runs for three years from the issue, or from the start of trading if later, and connection with the company is tested from two years before the issue.
Preferential rights
SEIS and EIS shares must be ordinary shares that, throughout the period, carry no preferential right to assets on a winding up and no right to be redeemed. A preferential dividend is allowed only if nobody can vary its amount or timing and unpaid dividends do not roll up. These rights sit in the articles and any shareholders' agreement, so check any change to either during the period. Our share structure page covers share classes.
Returns of value
Relief is reduced or withdrawn if the investor or an associate receives value from the company or a connected person, such as repayment of an earlier loan, a buy-back of their shares, a loan, a benefit or an overpayment for an asset. Receipts of no more than £1,000, or insignificant compared with the investment, are ignored unless they come under arrangements that existed in the 12 months before the issue. A buy-back from a shareholder who had no relief, such as a departing co-founder, can also reduce investors' relief.
Connected investors
An SEIS investor can be a director. They must not be an employee, and with their associates they must not hold more than 30% of the shares, votes or rights on a winding up from incorporation to the end of the period. Associates include a spouse or civil partner, parents, grandparents, children, grandchildren and business partners, and exclude brothers and sisters.
An EIS investor must not be an employee, a paid director or a holder of more than 30% from two years before the issue to the end of the period. A paid director can still qualify as a business angel if they had no earlier connection with the company or its trade and their pay is reasonable. An existing shareholder qualifies only if their earlier shares were subscriber shares or covered by a compliance statement.
Advance subscription agreements and loan notes
An advance subscription agreement lets an investor pay now for shares issued later. HMRC accepts one only if the money cannot be refunded in any circumstances, the agreement cannot be varied, cancelled or assigned, it carries no interest and it has a longstop date, which HMRC generally expects to be within six months of signing (VCM33025). A convertible loan note does not qualify, because the shares must be paid for in cash when issued and HMRC treats shares issued on conversion as the company repaying a debt (VCM15060).
Other events that break relief
Relief is also lost or reduced if the investor sells or gives away the shares within three years, other than to a spouse or civil partner, or grants or receives an option over them. The same happens if the company stops meeting a condition, for example by coming under another company's control or not spending the money in time.